San Francisco Podiatry Video


Monday, March 15, 2010

San Francisco Podiatrist on Difference Between Heel Pain and a Heel Spur

Heel pain is the most common form of foot pain that causes people in San Francisco to make an appointment with a podiatry clinic. In fact, nationwide, about 40% of all visits to podiatrists are due to heel pain diagnosed as plantar fasciitis. As a podiatrist in San Francisco myself, the thing that I find interesting is that most people with plantar fascitis think they must have a heel spur to have heel pain. But that’s not always true.

So what is the difference between plantar fasciitis and a heel spur?

To begin with, let’s explain how to tell if you have plantar fasciitis. Anyone with plantar fasciits will have pain in the bottom of the heel or in the arch. In most cases this pain is worse when you get up and step out of bed in the morning. The heel may also hurt when you get up from your desk after working at a computer for a couple of hours.

As you start to walk, the first step is usually a sharp pain or sudden ache in the bottom of the heel. After a few steps, the heel pain starts to subside and feels better. In many cases, it may not even hurt at all while you are walking around or even running. But when you sit still and get back up again to start walking, that’s when the heel pain returns.

If you have this kind of morning heel pain and simply push on the bottom of the heel (and it hurts) you most likely have plantar fasciitis.

Many people in the San Francisco Bay Area seem to believe that heel pain is due to a sharp heel spur poking down and causing pain. But in fact about half of all people who have this kind of heel pain don’t have a heel spur at all. And about half of people with no heel pain, happen to have a heel spur that will show up on x-ray. So the two problems aren’t necessarily related.

The most common cause of heel pain is plantar fasciitis, which is simply inflammation of the plantar fascia. The plantar fascia is a big ligament attaching to the bottom of the heel and extending out to the toes. If you put too much stress on the plantar fascia, it can become inflamed where it attached to the heel bone.

With improper biomechanics, such as excessive pronation (flat feet that roll inward as the arch collapses) the plantar fascia ligament may tug away at the heel bone. With tension applied to the plantar fascia, the attachment may cause the heel spur to form.

The way this happens is that the ligament pulls the covering (called the periosteum) of the heel bone away. A small blood clot forms and then becomes calcified as it heals. If this happens again and again, the heel spur gradually grows. Because the heel spur is caused by the pulling on this big ligament, you can understand why a heel spur points out toward the toes and not down toward the ground.

Any podiatrist in San Francisco can simply take an x-ray of your heel to tell whether or not you have a heel spur. But the reality is, it doesn’t matter.

In the last 7 years, I have only surgically removed 2 heel spurs. Both of them were broken and wouldn’t heal. One was an young ironworker in San Francisco who fell off some scaffolding while working on the Golden Gate Bridge retrofit project. The other was a woman in her sixties who has some osteoporosis and broke the heel spur while doing high impact aerobics.

But most people with plantar fasciitis can get better on their own, even if they have a heel spur. In the vast majority of cases, spending a few minutes doing our San Francisco Podiatry Heel Pain Recovery Stretches will make the heel pain go away. The spur just simply doesn’t usually need to be removed in surgery.

Dr. Christopher Segler is a nationally recognized expert on conditions affecting the heel bone. In 2006 he was awarded 1st Place at the National Meeting of the American Podiatric Medical Association for his research on diagnosing heel bone infections with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). He offers podiatry house calls in San Francisco for busy athletes and people who just think it is ridiculous to take half a day off work just to see a foot doctor. You can reach him through Doc On The Run: San Francisco Bay Area Podiatry House Calls.You can also learn more about the causes and available treatments for heel pain at

Want to learn more about running with heel pain?
FREE LIVE webinar with Doc On The Run:

Sign Up NOW


  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  2. Thank you very much. This site was more informative than my Doctor.